Call(561) 973-9998

A plain-language Florida guide for Palm Beach County

Replacement cost vs actual cash value: which one actually pays to rebuild your house

Reviewed by , Licensed Insurance AgentLast reviewed

The short version

If your house is ever damaged, replacement cost vs actual cash value decides whether the claim is figured on what repairs cost now or on what the damaged parts were worth after wear. Florida law requires an offer of replacement cost coverage, and law and ordinance coverage pays toward code upgrades when you rebuild.

  • Actual cash value subtracts wear and age from the payout.
  • Replacement cost pays to repair or rebuild, up to your limit.
  • No written refusal means law and ordinance coverage is included by default.

Call (561) 973-9998 and a licensed Florida agent runs the comparison with you.

Call (561) 973-9998Rather type it out? Use the form
Aerial view of the Boca Raton Resort's Mediterranean Revival buildings and pink tower, Boca Raton, Florida
The Boca Raton Resort, seen from the air

On BocaRatonInsuranceFL.com, Matt Williams, a licensed Florida insurance agent, explains the two ways a homeowner's claim can be valued and which one is built to cover a rebuild. The difference is easy to overlook while nothing is wrong, yet it decides how much of a repair the claim check covers.

The way your policy values a loss sets the size of the check

Actual cash value takes wear off the top

Actual cash value starts from what it would cost to replace the damaged part, then subtracts depreciation: the value used up by age and wear. The older the part, the more comes off, and that gap is yours to cover.

Replacement cost pays what it takes to put it back

Replacement cost values the loss at the price of repairing the damaged part, or of putting new material in its place, up to your policy limit, with nothing taken off for depreciation.

A kitchen fire, valued both ways

Say a fire ruins kitchen cabinets installed many years ago. Actual cash value starts from the price of new cabinets and subtracts the wear the old ones had taken, so it covers only part of a new set. Replacement cost figures the payment on new cabinets, up to your limit. Your deductible applies either way.

What rebuilding is measured against

  • $447,300median owner-occupied home value, 2020 to 2024
  • 1986median year a county home was built
  • 1.8%of units built in 2020 or later

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts; American Community Survey 2020-2024, table DP04; figures checked

You are owed a replacement cost offer before any policy is issued

Under s. 627.7011, before an insurer issues a homeowner's policy it must offer two versions of replacement cost on the dwelling, each capped at the policy limits:

  • Replacement cost alone. Losses that are repaired or replaced are settled at replacement cost instead of a depreciated value, but the added cost of meeting building laws and ordinances, including demolition and debris removal, is left out.
  • Replacement cost with law and ordinance coverage. The same settlement, plus those law and ordinance costs. The added coverage may be capped at "25 percent or 50 percent" of your dwelling limit, as the policyholder selects, and it covers only the damaged part of the house unless total damage tops 50 percent of the structure's replacement cost.

Without your written refusal, the statute treats any policy covering the dwelling as including law and ordinance coverage at 25 percent of the dwelling limit. Turning it down, or choosing something else, takes a form the Office of Insurance Regulation has approved. If a policy already pairs replacement cost with law and ordinance coverage at 25 percent, the company need not repeat the full set of offers, but it must still offer the 50 percent level.

The company must also remind you of the coverage at least once every 3 years, and every policy package, at issue and at renewal, must carry a bold notice urging you to discuss law and ordinance coverage with your agent.

Older houses are where law and ordinance coverage earns its keep

In Palm Beach County, the median year built for housing units is 1986, with 26.3% of units dating from the 1980s, 18.5% from the 1970s, 7.5% from the 1960s and 4.8% from the 1950s (American Community Survey, 2020 to 2024).

A house built under older rules can need more than a like-for-like repair to meet the rules in force when it is fixed. Replacement cost alone leaves that cost out; law and ordinance coverage pays it, up to the percentage you chose.

Set the dwelling limit on rebuilding cost, not market value

The median value of owner-occupied homes in Palm Beach County is $447,300 (Census QuickFacts, 2020 to 2024). That is a market figure, and market value is a different question from rebuilding cost. The dwelling limit counts in two places: replacement cost is capped at it, and the law and ordinance amount is a percentage of it, so a limit set too low trims both.

Roofs come with their own rules on age and inspections, covered in what Florida's roof-age rule protects.

Replacement Cost vs Actual Cash Value: the lines to check before a claim tests them

Pull your current policy and look for:

  • how the dwelling is settled: replacement cost, or a depreciated value
  • whether law and ordinance coverage is listed, and at which percentage
  • any written refusal of law and ordinance coverage you signed
  • the dwelling limit, which sets both the replacement cost cap and the law and ordinance amount
  • how your belongings are valued; the same statute has companies offer replacement cost on personal property with no holdback for depreciation, whether or not you replace the item

One company's version of these terms is only one version. Matt Williams works with several companies, and from one call he or another licensed agent on his team can show you how each would value a claim on your house. You get same day quotes and skip explaining the house again at every agency. A quote does not bind coverage or end the policy you have.

Start with home insurance in Boca Raton or call (561) 973-9998.

Replacement Cost Questions Before a Claim

Does replacement cost pay for code upgrades?

Not on its own. Under s. 627.7011, the first required offer leaves law and ordinance costs out, and the second adds them, at "25 percent or 50 percent" of your dwelling limit, your choice.

Can a company refuse replacement cost on an older house?

It can, for underwriting reasons. The statute says its offer rules do not limit a company's ability to reject or nonrenew a structure that misses its underwriting criteria for replacement cost or law and ordinance policies. Those criteria belong to each company, so one refusal is not the whole market's answer.

Is the county's median home value a sensible dwelling limit?

Not by itself. It is a market figure for owner-occupied homes across the county, not the cost to rebuild yours. Set the limit on rebuilding cost, and have a licensed agent walk through it with you.

Still weighing it?

Go through your declarations page with a licensed Florida agent; there is no charge for the call.

(561) 973-9998Or leave your details

Compare before the renewal arrives

Describe what you have once. A licensed Florida agent checks it against several companies for Boca Raton, Palm Beach County and nearby towns, and the decision stays yours.

Call (561) 973-9998Start a quote online